The Unfinished Tales - favorite story - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Vanya · 05-06-2004, 07:12 AM

Well, reading UT was splendid experience for me, almost as reading Silmarilion. I liked everything, but the story that made deepest impression was story of Rohan.
I liked how the battle on the river Isen was described, since it told so much about Rohhirim man, their spirit, way of life, courage, tactics, and of some heroes that haven't been (unfortunately) mentioned in LOTR. It gave me quite different perspective on battle in Helm's Deep.
However, what realy swept me away, was part when Cirion, the Stuart of Gondor, brought Eorl and selected few to secret grave of Elendil, to make an oath of alience and friendship to each other, as well as to make a valuable present (land of Calenardon) in return for the assistance in the battle.
It represented the real spirit of ME, and was so optimistc too.

05-06-2004, 07:12 AM	#1
Vanya Animated Skeleton Join Date: Mar 2004 Location: Belgrade Posts: 43	The Unfinished Tales - favorite story Well, reading UT was splendid experience for me, almost as reading Silmarilion. I liked everything, but the story that made deepest impression was story of Rohan. I liked how the battle on the river Isen was described, since it told so much about Rohhirim man, their spirit, way of life, courage, tactics, and of some heroes that haven't been (unfortunately) mentioned in LOTR. It gave me quite different perspective on battle in Helm's Deep. However, what realy swept me away, was part when Cirion, the Stuart of Gondor, brought Eorl and selected few to secret grave of Elendil, to make an oath of alience and friendship to each other, as well as to make a valuable present (land of Calenardon) in return for the assistance in the battle. It represented the real spirit of ME, and was so optimistc too.