The Problem of Rog

[Mithadan]

Worthy of note on this issue is a webpage called Tyalie Tyelellieva maintained by a Tolkien Language group which split off from the "Elfconners". This page, which contains substantive materials (and is critical of the "secretive" Elfconners) includes a list of unpublished materials. One of the entries is as follows:

§33. Name-list to the Fall of Gondolin, described and quoted from in Lost Tales, but only part of it was quoted in publication.

This list is said to be in the possession of Carl Hostetter and was copied at the Bodleian Library. I have no personal experience with Mr. Hostetter. The webpage claims that he and his colleagues do not share unpublished materials with others (and is highly critical of these persons). I do not know if this is true. However, research at the Tolklang list might achieve some results (if this hasn't already been done).