I now pronounce you Dwarf & Hobbit...oops!

[davem]

Originally Posted by the guy who be short

It's as if the house had hidden rooms which nobody had ever explored; the rest of the house may have been red and blue, but those rooms may well have been green.

Yes, but the architect, builder & painter - particularly if they're the same person - would know whether there are other rooms & would be responsible for the colour.

Originally Posted by Bb

Like any mythology, that of Middle-earth will be retold and reinterpreted by those whose imaginations if not stomachs are whetted by its cauldron of strange stew. In such cases, those new works will stand or fall not on their debt or faithfulness to Tolkien, but on the extent to which they also provide imaginative sustenance.

But this 'mythology' has Tolkien's name on it, & is copyrighted. Hence it is not a 'mythology' in the true sense & can't be treated as one. The question is how faithful the players want the game to be. Of course, you can include anything you want in the game - you just wouldn't be able to claim it was Tolkien's world if you introduced things into it that weren't true to Tolkien.

Its interesting that there seems to be much more interest in both this game & the stage show than in, for instance, Rateliff's History of TH - which is actually one of the most significant events in recent times - second only to CoH. I suppose this tells us a lot about what 'fans' want & we must each draw our own conclusions.