Lommy these are the "Classic" taters to choose from:
Taniquetil
The Void
Galadriel
Elendil the Tall
Gorgoroth
The Noldor
Samwise Gamgee
The Last Alliance
Gandalf the White
And exactly like Huorn - Fangorn, it appears 2 of you are on the same wavelength this round:
Mandos
Doom of Mandos