Nilp, you're forgetting that the GW can also get rid of wolves by turning them to ordos. (Or at least, failing to mention it...)
Mac, I'm sorry about that, but it goes with the territory (agree with you = good, disagree = bad). Still, I'll give you this - I usually only see you doing that early in the game. Later on, as I've always said, you're one of the best wolf-hunters out there. As you're better as an innocent than as a wolf, if I were the EW, I'd kill you or try to get you lynched, rather than scry you. Also, the EW should know that I
will catch you if you are a wolf, sooner or later!
(BTW, whenever people mention the EW, I feel slightly like they're talking about me - my initials used to be E.W., and soon will be again.)
Well, I think I'll make a list - however, not everybody's gonna be on it, because I'll have to make another trip back to
Noggie's post to remember everyone's name. So, those I have the strongest views on first:
____ - Whatever he is trying to do, it isn't helping the village. YesterDay I thought he was just trying to stir the pot and get people talking, a day 1 technique I approve of, but toDay he is defensive and overly focused on
Roa's attacks. He felt good yesterDay, but feels less good toDay. Sure, an EW who would scry such an obvious choice would be a bold one - but that might be what we have.
Roa - Her attacks on the poster formerly known as
The Phantom were indeed a little hasty - not always accurately representing his posts. She may just be letting irritation with
tp overcome her judgement, but she's also one of those who gave me the "go after so-and-so toDay" vibe. I actually find both of them somewhat suspicious, and wouldn't reject the possibility they're both evil.
Macalaure - He seems like his innocent self to me. I trust him so far, and am confident I will spot him if he's turned into a wolf. I know, saying that has gotten me in trouble before, but there it is.
Aganzir - She did seem nervous yesterday to me, and I find that hard to figure out, because I have always thought she was one who could keep her cool under pressure. One thing about her is if I were a wizard, I would have had her on my list - not that that means anything.
Nilp - Has been sensible enough so far. I don't like his last post, though - misleading, demoralizing to the village.
Dury - Looks innocent to me. I think I have finally gotten used to her personality, which I always found wolfish in the past - her attitude makes me think she is an ordo now, though.
Brin - Has been bugging me. I'll have to go back and look at her posts, but my general impression has been of a sort of scattered, irrational pattern.
McCobbler- Hopped on a bandwagon yesterday, and he is, of course, the ultimate submarine.
Sally and
Gwath have both struck me as being unusually devoted in this game -
Sally more serious than usual, and
Gwatn more vocal. Not sure what to make of that.
the rest later...
EDIT: X'd with everybody since Mac.