Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Boro
I'm not following the difficulty you (and sally, Pitch yesterday) appear to be having with the messages from the ghosts? They've been brilliantly clear in making sure the accurate information is given.
|
I could be offended, but I'm deciding not to. Yes, I agree toDay's messages have been clear. YesterDay's, nope. And I am saying the dead are not infallible. I very much doubt
G55 straightaway gave them
Sori's alignment. Therefore, they must have concluded it from some more vague information they got. Does this mean that it is foolproof? NO. Does it mean that we should trust it for toDay? Certainly. Does it mean that we should trust it for the rest of the game, if it goes on? I think so. I mean frankly, we don't have the time to suspect someone who is 95% likely innocent. If
Soriman is a wolf somehow and we lose because of that, I'm gonna blame the dead thread. So we can discount him for now. As I belive I said before, so I don't know why you dedicated a whole post to "arguing against me". Makes me think you want to keep the village talking about information we already have, ie
Soriman's innocence, instead of looking for the wolves.
And
Huin seems to be repeating this too, and also repeating the dead suspect
Pitchwife but they are not certain. I only wonder what
Soriman being "not hostile to elves" means, if it means anything. Does it mean that he's not hostile to
Galadriel55 ie didn't eat her ie is innocent? Or does it mean he is not hostile to me or
Morsul (since we're the ones with Sindarin usernames) and the dead think we're all innocent? Or even know something?
Pitch, I'm not sure if I'm reading correctly, yesterDay you seem to both question
Sally and believe her in #368 before proceeding to legate-180 on her - can you explain your flipflop?
Legate, so you don't think
Boro and
Pitch are packmates, but rather that one is a wolf with
Morsul or me? Hmm I wonder why is that, because currently I think most likely packs are either
Legate-
Boro or
Legate-
Pitch... (Or
Boro-
Morsul, but if they are, I wouldn't honestly mind them winning because they'd have been doing an insanely good job.)
Now off to look at Day2, hoping it will either prove or disprove the
Legate-
Boro theory...
edit: xed with Legate