Ha! I just had another look through and the person I pinpointed was
Firefoot.
Her vote seems a bit...I don't know. It seems quite reasonable but also easy. Especially voting that early.
Gil-Galad because he talks about himself being suspicious, even though he was only (to my mind) playing the Confused Philosopher role.
And voting for
Boromir88 because of his guessing in the innocence of some and not of others. I'm not sure. It seems a bit convenient to me. And I think an innocent might have added another qualifier, such as "Of course, I'm really not sure."
She seems too reasonable and it's getting to your heads. I think we should lynch her.