Oh and I forgot to mention about
McCab - I think he was innocent. There's not much to conclude from his posts and his lynch was a shot in the dark and those tend to go awry. But we can look at his and Mira's deaths the way that at least they're both people who probably have a higher than average tendency to miss the vote and that's why it's better they're dead not someone else - although by this standard we should lynch
Nerwen even though she's almost a known innocent.
Okay, now off to me list:
Sally - too slippery fer me, bears watching
Rikae - back to the aggressive
Rikae mode - what does it mean?
Inziladun - too smooth fer me taste, but I have no picture of an innocent
Zil to compare his current behaviour to, so it's hard to say anything definite...
Boromir - my special
boroscope radar
is judging him innocent, but then again, I'm sure me
boroscope's gonna fail some day and it may just as well be in this game...
Wilwa - as slippery and watching-worthy as
Sally, I just have a slightly better gut-feeling about her
Shasta - I think he's innocent but I have nothing concrete to back this up
Annu - could be anything, I need to see more of her to judge better
Mac - seems innocent but I know better than to trust my judgement of him
Nerwen - by all mathematical odds is most likelily an innocent
Kath - her normal self ie unreadable until Day4 or 5
Gwath - I'd like him to post more, I have little idea of him but I'm not too suspicious...
Nogrod - seems rather innocent except for the rather weird
Annu-vote
Izzy - I like what I'm seeing this far
Mith - probably an innocent?
Eönwë - I'm sorry to say this, but I'm not worried about him because I think he will incriminate himself soon enough if he's evil
So my best guess at the mutineer team is
Wilwa +
Sally +
Nogrod/
Rikae +
Inziladun/
Annu/
Eönwë. (Mmh why to format it that way is because it is kind of probable that there aren't two gurus or two relative newcomers in the team.)
I just realised that with two co-conspies and four mutineers, more than a third of the living are probably evil. (I think there are no dead mutineers yet,
Eomer or
McCab may have been a co-conspirator, but I don't know how probable is that...) We have to be really careful then about trusting people and remember that the evil-doers can form quite a mighty consensus...
edit: xed with everyone