Quote:
Originally Posted by Eönwë
The village voted Kit because of this post!?  |
A straight answer, I think, would be "no". But it would be a part of the reasoning for some (like me). I mean it's not only the "slip" (which turned out not to be a slip after all) of kind of letting it be seen in between the lines that she knows no lions were mentioned aka. she knows who they are because she is one herself - but also that it defends
Mac who then turned out a lion...
But I think her relation with
Mac (mutual) were the first reasons to vote for her - and her own votes the second reason, this maybe coming as the third important or something... but yeah, let's continue as these cases have been argued like dozen times already by several people. So I mean next time someone asks "why did you lynch
Kit" I'd only say "read the thread" as many people have stated these reasons quite clearly quite many times already.
But this spotting by
Eönwë I do appreciate as at least I had totally overseen/forgotten it:
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Inzil
Well, in Mac's shoes I'd have thought it too risky.
|
So does he imply he knew
Mac was a lion? It as also interestin g to follow the bickering between
Mac and
Inzil recollected. Somehow it feels a bit overdone if they would be both lions, but it is also possible that with both gaining suspicions and them tslking themselves into these dead-end alleys they were kind of forced to follow their susoicions with votes... Who knows? But certainly one more scenario to mull over - or at least one we should not overlook.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Rikae
Nog is the one who's really bothering me toDay, math aside. I just get a feeling he's trying to subtly steer conversation in unhelpful directions.
|
Like urging us to concentrate on the lionhunt - and speaking against wasting time on Bear-speculations? Like saying let's go back to Mac-bussiness as that is where we have any hints there could be? Very unhelpful direction indeed... Could you
Rikae tell us which would be more helpful directions?
