Quote:
Originally Posted by Sauron the White
Yes, I have read the posts and understand that many other EW selections on this list have been attacked. But is that not to give the tar and feather treatment to the very idea of putting LOTR on the list? After all, if you can show that there are silly or worthless selections on the list, then it also calls into doubt the inclusion of LOTR in such a lofty position doesn't it?
|
I thought that's what you meant.
a.) I do not think all the films on that list are particularly good.
b.) I do think the LotR films are good films.
According to you, it is impossible to hold both these positions.
The part I can't work out,
Sauron, is
why we all feel the need to resort to such subterfuge. Do explain. I'm dying of curiosity.
P.S. It's
Nerwen, not
Nerewen.