[QUOTE=Elrian]Luthien would choose mortal death, and a few years later, Valinor would see its only real, true, lasting mortal death.
Quote:
First maybe, could be that the Hobbits (Bilbo, Frodo, Samwise) and Dwarf (Gimli) also died in the West, as they were granted passage while they yet lived. 
|
True. I should have said first, not only, but I suppose in the context of Valinor meaning Valinor, and not including Tol Eressia, I am still right, but it's a very fine distinction, and perhaps a ridiculous one to make.