Cos lists are rather lovely. (Numbers in parentheses are post #s where I drew my conclusion.)
Probably Guilty (
My main suspects.)
Kuruharan (NIGHT kill! +
311)
Brinniel (
275)
Firefoot (
290)
Somewhat Worrying (
Thinking innocent, but with a soupçon of . . . suspicion. 
)
Formendacil (
315)
Nogrod (
299 &
324)
Feanor of the Peredhil (
292)
Must Watch (
Being quite hard to read for now.)
Alonariel
Lariren Shadow
satansaloser2005
Isabellkya
Reassuring (
Cos I like the way they think.)
Kent2010 (
300)
Shatanis Althreduin (
321 &
323)
Gwathagor (
351)
Slacker (
Having so much fun with this game.)
Nilpaurion Felagund
~*~*~*~
I'm already forming possible Baddie interactions manifesting themselves during the DAY, and all I'm lacking is
that one clue.
Most likely I'll vote for
Kuru, and use my bonus votes while I'm at it, too.