Yes, and I while any reviewer for the TLS is likely to be extremely erudite, he really seems to have grasped it very well - both the scope (and the arguable flaws). I must see if I can find any thing about the reviewer and if (like Auden and Lewis he knew Tolkien and would have been aware of the wider mythology. I really do think it is most perceptive. I think I need to get a paper copy of this weeks TLS..
Edit... assume it was this chap
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alfred_Duggan
An Oxford man but not of an era to have been taught by Tolkien so assume not a favour to a friend....