Quote:
Originally Posted by Formendacil
It has occurred to me to make a list of people and rate them based on my impressions--but more than half the village would fall under "hasn't said enough for me to have any idea."
|
Well, did you see my list?
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Rikae
It doesn't require elaborate choosing of spokespeople, just an agreement well before the deadline. The strategy won't make sense if the village gets very small, because the extra vote will carry too much weight in its own right, but early on, it could be very valuable.
It's interesting how many people are arguing that it either can't be done or is somehow oppressive. And by interesting, I mean suspicious.
|
I'm only skeptical how the village will reach an agreement that the dead consider enough of an agreement to act on it. Then again, given how we're toDay kind of sliding towards an agreement that we'll vote as normal and not try to orchestrate a tie, maybe you're right and I'm just being pessimistic. The bottom line being (sorry for being the Captain Obvious here!) we can't of course know whether an "organic" direction by the living towards the dead thread will work or not until we've tried it. (There is a voice in my head asking if we'll know it even after we've tried it, but I'm getting too tired to think it through.)
As for those who consider such direction oppressive, well, I think it's an emotional knee-jerk reaction, and while I don't think they've thought it through, I can definitely see where they're coming from so I don't personally find it very suspicious.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Nog
The Phantom then would be really cool Day1 wolf-lynch, something worth an anniversary -game!
|
We can hardly pat ourselves on the back for lynching
the phantomwolf on Day1 if we do it just because he's
the phantom. Also I'm starting to get a little suspicious of
Nog's push to lynch
the phantom despite not even suspecting him. Just, why would you do that?
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Nog
which goes for Lommy too (even if I do wonder her insistence on the spokesperson -idea)
|
Just nitpicking a little, I didn't
insist on the spokesperson idea, I merely suggested it. But for the record I think it's still worth thinking about, even though I can't really see how it would be orchestrated without wasting a horrible amount of time and energy. It's very much worth keeping in mind if we ever have a known innocent though.
In any case, I'm going to sleep now as it's past 3am (oops - how I've missed werewolf!
). Choose well.