I thought you had acknowledged that we had come to an impasse.
What response can there be to your examples save "I disagree"? I don't think any of those are among Tolkien's greatest passages, but I don't find any of them disgusting either.
If there is going to be a debate over whether particular passages sound good or not, it will be interminable.
[ November 06, 2003: Message edited by: Aiwendil ]
|