As long as we're looking to restructure the RPG Forum, perhaps we should take a look at the rules which are in place now:
SHIRE RULES: The Red Book of Westmarch
The Golden Hall: Rohan Rules/Player Lists
What needs to go, what do you think should be kept? (Note: the rule forbidding swearing, sexual conduct, and obscenity was a requirement by the Barrow-Wight.)