Quote:
Originally Posted by FlimFlamSam
In a nut-shell, without my bias; The Silmarillion was never finished because Mr. Tolkien never really wanted to finish it, and it shows when reading it.
|
I disagree. I don't think it was Tolkien's goal to complete a book for the sake of completing it. He never wrote books for people to
like them; he wasn't like the many modern authors writing what the audience expects them to. JRRT wrote what he thought was the right thing to write, not something that would "catch".
JRRT never made it his goal to finish The Sil, that's true. But one of his goals was to make his writings
right. New ideas kept comming, and, as you well know, Tolkien was not an Elf.
You can see that The Sil was unfinished, but, personally, I never had the feeling that JRRT "didn't want to finish it". He didn't want to complete it until he was sure everthing was
right, true, but that's different from what you say.
I will add myself to those asking you to quote others differently (like I did above). It makes posts much easier to read.
ETA:
Quote:
Originally Posted by FlimFlamSam
Nerwen spoke: [he's just trying to pick fights. It's obvious.]
And... you'd be wrong again, on both counts.
|
Well, it sure seems to me that
Nerwen is right in this one. Maybe you can try phrasing your thoughts differently, so that we'll see that we're wrong?