Quote:
Originally Posted by Faramir Jones
|
Another one of those "assumption" examples where it seems like Peter Jackson needed to put down the
Dungeons & Dragons manual (or perhaps the
Warhammer army book) and actually pick up one of Professor Tolkien's stories.
Wouldn't it have been so much more original and refreshing in this film if, instead of going for the pop-culture cliché, they had followed
the actual book they were meant to be adapting so that the Dwarves were the stuffy aristocratic ones who took themselves too seriously and the Elves were the light-hearted, humorous merrymakers? I suppose Thorin still takes himself far too seriously in the film.
In any event, one can't help but find it bizarre that Professor Tolkien's imitators have so much influence that it creates mistrust in his own stories, such that people are inclined, despite everything, to see his Elves as work-shy posh weirdoes and his Dwarves as drunken Scotsmen in comedy Viking helmets.