I don't believe you can say that an elf is the greatest because of one quote. Luthien got a silmaril from Morgoth, and that was it. Although it was a great deed, what about elves like Fingolfin, who crossed Helcaraxe and had a duel against Morgoth? Or Glorfindel, who killed a balrog and whom even the nazgūl feared? I think it is wrong to rely so much on a single quote, and that you can't decide who is the greatest elf, because it cannot be measured.
__________________
Two beer or not two beer, that is the question; by Shakesbeer
|