[William Cloud Hicklin]

Quempel:

The doctrine invoked by the Estate (to the extent I can judge by the press reports) is that when a party to a contract breaches it materially, outrageously and in bad faith, the aggrieved party can ask the court to nullify the contract.

Let's look at it this way: suppose Farmer Jones contracts to sell this year's and next year's crop to a wholesaler. After Year 1 the wholesaler doesn't pay a penny- it's hardly unreasonable then for Farmer Jones not to give them Year 2's crop for nothing as well.

Mind you, this applies only to New Line- Saul Zaentz would still be free to license TH to any other studio. MGM/UA might be interested because they already own the distribution rights. And this other studio would be free to hire Peter Jackson if desired.


The Board of the Tolkien Estate* comprises Christopher, his wife Baillie, and JRRT's grandson Michael George Tolkien. All three appear to have the same attitude towards visual (as opposed to audio) adaptations. There's no telling in advance who might take up Christopher's vote on the board, but the most likely candidate is son Adam, whose position is also very book-centric and anti-exploitation.

*That's not strictly accurate- it's actually the board of The Tolkien Company Ltd, whereas the Estate is run by its executors, CRT and Cathleen Blackburn; and the Tolkien Trust has its own Board which includes JRRT's daughter Priscilla.