Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Sauron the White
Please... please ... no patronizing lectures from on high about my being off topic. The topic here was "or no hobbits at all". And you keep talking about the use of Elvish in the LOTR films. Seems the pot is calling the kettle black.
|
In my last post I admitted the languages were off-topic here.
And earlier when you began (post
83):
'What does it matter to the construction, flow and success of LOTR as a film...' (see above) I responded with:
'That's a different discussion that I have not really entered into here. If you want to start a new thread on it I will be happy to read it and maybe contribute.'
In any case, the issue is not so much topic, but the topic in context.
Quote:
|
All I am trying to do is discuss an issue you posted about here. With all due respect to you, I reserve the right to approach it in the way I feel is best. Thank you.
|
Feel free. You don't need to quote something from my posts to form a soapbox for your opinions on 'film success' however.
And intended or not, I feel you are misrepresenting my argument by doing so, as the contexts are different (for example [currently] post
88).
I have no problem with you giving your opinion on accuracy in general but at the end of post
91 it seems implied that my argument concerning 'accuracy' is something it is not; and it only takes a few moments to word a post for better clarity in this regard.