I have to read over all these posts again to get everything straight in my mind, but two things occured to me:
Yes, Cami should be there, but is there something that Cami has from Gondolin that would be recognized by the cave Hobbits in order to "seal the deal"? Some token or artifact that would mean something to them? Or a song perhaps?
Slitting the guards' throats would be easy for a hobbit - as long as they are laying down. Otherwise, you may need some kind of 2-hobbit assault. One to bring the Men to their knees, the other to slit aforementioned throats. Some kind of club to the knee, or a well-aimed stone to the...well, someplace that's sensitive?
|