Though I can definitely tell you that we can find nothing out for real, we can have a lot of fun lynching...
And, anyway, Sam was the one who hurts Shelob, not me. I'm comatose in Rivendell by then...
Does everyone realize that the werewolves are going to be the one who will speak the least! (Now how many are going to speak up after I say that?)
I might add that Feanor did cast the first stone...
bilbo_baggins