Quote:
Originally Posted by Findegil
Most of the texts we work with are just tales! For me The Table of Adanel and the philosophy of Athrabeth would no longer work at all, if Men would have some dealings with other Ainur or incarnates. The Voice is asking them to learn from expirence not from others. And the interpretation of the gift as presented in the Athrabeth seems to me only possible when you can't compare it to the longvety of the Elves or imortility of the Ainur.
Therefore I think Nuin can't wacke Ermon and Elmir an dhas to leave the newly awoken Men to same self for a time.
Respectfully
Findegil
|
The text in the NoME doesn't necessarily mean that the original Men had messengers sent to them
immediately after their Awakening (especially since the said text outright states that Eru sent
messages to the original Men too).
Also, Men have notoriously unreliable memories - especially across multiple generations!