[samrohan]

The role of Bilbo if ever the filming of The Hobbit will take place should be given to an unknown actor.<BR>I understand why CT feels betrayed by Newline in terms of them not following his fathers book and inventing new twists to the storyline. I felt let down by many scenes and changes when watching the Fellowship of the Rings, but thanks to the excellent filming and marvellous directing from PJ, I forgave him by the second movie and I am looking forward to seeing all these endings the previews are talking about.<P>It is trust that a movie cannot follow a book to the T. Some liberties should be taken. It actually hurts me to say this as I don't entirelly forgive all PJs changes.<P>I however would love to see PJ direct the Hobbit, but I wonder if he would be willing to direct it, as it would be less of a challenge after the LOTR.<P>" As long as he does not over-feature celebs like he did for Liv Tyler", my biggest grudge.