I have spent a lot of time in this game writing post summaries and I don't have the time now since I want to look at all of
Kath,
Sally,
Boro, and
Legate, so you'll just have to bear with my impressions:
Kath
On Day1, possibly to avoid wolvish attention,
Kath didn't single anyone out as particularly wolvish or innocent. She voted for
Morsul. Day2 she heavily suspected
Sally based on
Form's death and voted for her, and she also suspected all of the
Hui-
Legate-
Boro trio to a degree, but unlikely dreamed of any of them (especially unlikely in the case of
Huin ). Defended
Lottie. Conclusions?
Sally and
Lottie were likely seer dreams.
Day3 then? Speculates a
Sally/
Lommy/
Pitch pack, also suspects
Legate. Makes it clear that "
sally I think is a wolf regardless of the other two" but otherwise making no clear ranking of suspiciousness between others. Ergo likely didn't dream of anyone else (and well, I can tell you with 100% certainty that she didn't dream of me, or she wouldn't have wasted her time suspecting me). Later voices more suspicion of
Pitch based on his communication with
Sally. Also looks at
Morsul but doesn't conclude anything concrete about his guilt/innocence, so safe to say she didn't dream of him either. Says she's tempted to think
Soriman is a wolf and says almost nothing at all about
Boro; if we trust the dead, she cannot have dreamed of guilty!
Sori and I think she'd have mentioned if she had serious reasons to believe
Boro was guilty or innocent. So I'm a little swamped about dream #3, my guess is that she actually only dreamed of
Sally AFTER suspecting her on Day2 to confirm/prove it, and one of her earlier dreams was someone who died (basically
Greenie or
Form). I guess it's also possible she dreamed of a
Wolfwife on N3, but I'd think she'd have come out in that case. Also that doesn't really add up with the "
sally is a wolf regardless" comment.
Sally
Day1 was her infamous quiet Day, and she did not vote. On Day2 she says she would vote for
Lottie (for aggression) or
Lommy (gut instinct), has no idea about
Hui,
Sori and
Legate, and would not vote
Boro,
Pitch,
Morsul, or
Kath. Defended
Pitch quite vocally by her standards (give that she was quite quiet in this game), and voted for
Lottie. I do think wolf!
Sally could defend
Pitch regardless of his role - to buddy up with an innocent, but she could just as well defend a fellow openly and trust to get away with it.
Day3 has again more material, and it's here stuff gets more interesting. She refused to buy into the "one of
Sally /
Morsul /
Pitch is guilty" theory as long as she could. Instead she kept saying
Morsul is likely misguided innocent and didn't say anything about
Pitch. Said she "would vote"
Kath,
Legate,
Lommy or
Sori, and "wouldn't vote"
Boro,
Morsul or
Pitch. She tried to make a case against me, and agreed with
Boro's point against
Legate. Didn't really specify why she put anyone else in any particular category, if I'm correct. Then later in the day she seems to have flipped - perhaps after it started to look like a majority of the village was willing to vote for her, or maybe after enough people explained the dead thread message to her - and she amended that maybe
Morsul or
Pitch could be a wolf after all. Later she tried to fake she was the seer and she'd dreamed of innocent
Boro and
Morsul, and try to get the village vote for
Kath with her. Says
Pitch is more likely a wolf than
Morsul. Says "Et tu,
Boro?" when
Boro votes for her.
Comments: A lot to unpack here, especially with the votes against her combined. Let me just comment individually how likely packmates I consider everyone for
Sally, in the order which they voted for her:
#1
Morsul: was the first one to vote for
Sally, right at the beginning of the Day, and kept pressing at her lynch throughout the Day.
Sally kept defending him 'til the end. Now this would have been an insanely bold move from wolf
Morsul. Remember, we know now
Sally was lynched, but there was no way the wolves would have known she was doomed from the beginning of the Day. A sacrifice like
Morsul's would have been an unnecessary prolonging of the game from their pov. I mean I guess it's possible the wolves thought
Sally was toast and decided to bus her from the beginning of the Day, but I'd think they'd have preferred to have tried to win the game yesterDay.
Sally's insistence in
Morsul's innocence could have been to make herself look better (I don't think knee jerk suspicion of
Morsul would have helped her case), or I guess more sinister if she didn't want to make
Morsul another lynch option when the pack had already decided to bus her, not him.
#2
Kath
#3
Boro - now his and mine (#4) were the decisive ones. (Had voting for
Sally stopped at 3 votes and someone else got 3 too, the outcome would have been up to the dead thread. So number #3 made
sally an almost certain lynch candidate and #4 sealed it.) Normally, I would say that this would be a credit to
Boro, but given that nobody except
Pitchwife and myself to a lesser degree seemed to be considering
sally's reveal could be genuine, bussing her at this point would have been a clever move for
Wolfomir88. (Also,
Boro didn't even consider
Sally's reveal could have been genuine. Somewhat typical
Boro-singlemindedness, or was he so sure she wasn't genuine because he knew?)
Sally's continued trust in
Boro makes me raise my eyebrows, but then again, "Et tu,
Boro?" would be pretty bold against a fellow wolf. But then again,
Sally is bold. Idk. To be honest, my feelings towards
Boro in this game can be summed up in two words: intense paranoia, ok and also the following three: second-guessing everything.
#4 me
#5
Soriman, whom I'm not going to analyse
#6
Legate - a late vote that does him little credit. He'd have voted for
Sally at this point regardless of his role. She threw him in her suspicious category earlier during Day3 but didn't contribute very much to making an actual case against him - this is another piece of non-information, if you ask me. I think the wolves would likely not have turned against each other in the first half of the day since they could still have won by lynching an innocent - but then again, putting him in a "suspicious" category but only proceeding to make one (1) unoriginal point against him would hardly make
Legate more likely to get lynched.
#7
Pitchwife - as has been pointed out almost ad nauseam toDay, he looks the worst in conjuction with
Sally. She considered him innocent earlier, on Day3 considered him innocent without drawing extra attention to him (she didn't claim to have "seer dreamed" of him unlike about
Morsul and
Boro, but she kept him safely in her innocent category without really saying anything to draw attention to him either before or after her reveal, except for a somewhat belated "ok if one of me,
Morsul and
Pitch is a wolf, it has to be
Pitch", which is understandable, because she had just claimed she dreamed of innocent
Morsul.) I still think the
Pitch-
Sally interaction is a little fishy, but as I said before, I can also sympathise with
Pitch. I mean if you're an ordo, can you really rightaway disregard a seer reveal, however unlikely the source? Perhaps
Pitch looks foul but feels fair. However, this game has proven that both my reason and my gut-feeling can be equally wrong, so I'm hesitating to draw any conclusions.
Ok leaving
Legate and
Boro for the next post, and focusing on that weird dance with
Huin on D2 because I don't have the time to go through all their verbiose posts, and D1 I think is likely not that telling and D3 is in my fresh memory... then I'm also gonna look at wolf-packs. My current options are
Morsul-
Boro (who'd have decided to bus
Sally),
Legate-
Pitch (would look maybe the most likely in regards to
Sally I guess), or
Legate-
Boro (downright insane but absolutely actually quite plausible and also sounds like we would be done for). Individually I think
Morsul looks the most innocent, but I'm on the fence about the other three.
But now,
Legate just came home and we're gonna make dinner, so a little break from ww first. Wish us luck that we won't stab each other with kitchen knives, it's absolutely insane to be in the same apartment on a Day like this.
(Don't play ww with your significant others, children, it might be detrimental to your relationship and/or mental health!)
Also I'm gonna cross-post with everyone because I've been writing this for almost two hours (jeez).