[Rumil]

Too right Lommy!!!

Please just try and get it right this time PJ, or at least put the rubbish bits on different DVD sections that don't affect the plot, so I can flick past them.

The good bits of LoTR really were excellent in my view, the cinematography, Gandalf in the Shire, the Misty Mountains, the Balrog etc. what was annoying was how easy it would have been to get some of the rubbish bits right.

Someone should do an edited Tolkienite version of maximum canonicity, maybe one day it could be revamped in CGI to get rid of the elves from Helm's Deep and the ready-brek skeletons from the Pelennor Fields.