Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Brinniel
Whoever mentioned that his behaviour seems cobblerish, I agree. The problem is we don't even know whether we have a cobbler or not.
|
Bolding mine.
Now, I may be wrong, but it seems to me that I would have said "whether there is a cobbler" rather than "whether we have a cobbler". Honest mistake, slip of the tongue?
There's also
Brinn's vote for
Nerwen, which (granted,
Brinn's not been here much due to RL to talk more about her vote) seems odd to me. I can't really recall
Nerwen ever attacking
Boro, rather than just disagreeing with him (there's that distinction again!).
Now for
Nerwen, mostly for her vote - out of nowhere, last moment, and certain death for
Mac had it been counted/
Legate's event hadn't happened.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Nerwen
++Mac
for dodgy reasoning.
|
Now, the only place I can find where
Nerwen even mentioned
Mac is in #67, quoted below:
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Nerwen
Mac, even on your own terms that doesn't make sense... because in fact ignoring an innocent Boro would also be a possible wolvish response– I should say a probable one. At least one wolf nearly always keeps out of the limelight.
Meanwhile, it being Day One, peculiar statements are going to draw attention. There's not much else to go on, after all. Boro has been saying something perfectly obvious as though it's a revelation; sometimes he seems to be be saying we should lynch on that basis and sometimes not... and if not, I don't see why he's going on about it.
As for your saying I'm "attacking" him and being "sinister"... no idea where you're getting that from.
EDIT:X'd with some Morsuls and Greenies. Also the mod.
|
Firstly, since when does pointing out that something's been omitted from a comment invalidate the rest of the comment? Secondly, the point you make about ignoring
Boro being a possible wolf tactic has merit, but not against
Mac as he didn't just ignore
Boro.
Long story short, not seeing any "dodgy reasoning" here. I don't trust
Nerwen's vote at all, I think that she's a wolf who tried to either kill
Mac or save
Inzil (or possibly
Mnemo... all three scenarios have interesting connotations) and I think that if
Nerwen does turn out a wolf, then
Brinn is also a likely wolf (because her vote looks awfully wolf-on-wolf to me).