Quote:
|
Say we work out that Hurin was 0.00001% better than his son. Does that mean that if they played out a one-on-one fight 100 times that Hurin would always win? Of course not.
|
Entirely true. Then again, figuring out that Hurin is "0.00001%" better than Turin is exactly what this thread is for, since he would be, by a small margin, a better fighter.
Not that I think Hurin is. I'd be inclined to give Turin the edge, but you're right that they both should be near the top (if not at the top).
Quote:
|
Gil-Galad, Aragorn, Eowyn and Elindil
|
Leave Eowyn off and it might be a decent list. And saying "Elendil" would make it even better.
Quote:
|
Eowyn may not seem that good
|
Because she's not good enough to be on that list.
Quote:
|
but she did kill the Witch-King
|
She happened to be the one standing there when he was made vulnerable by Merry's magic sword.
Quote:
|
not that many people could have done that
|
Rosie Cotton could've done that.
Stab the guy in the face with a sword while he's just sitting there. Who can't do that?