Well then, I've read the thread and all this cobbler-talk obviously stands out. Some of it strikes me as silly, and some of it strikes me as right sinister, as it is strictly theoretical at this point without any cobbler suspects and is therefore a distraction from more important business, that is, deciding on a name. I fear that what we are hearing are the treacherous tongues of Sauron.
Some other impressions.
Green is being captain obvious.
Nerwen is the one most determined to stay in character whatever that means...
Boro chides people for posting too long then promptly posts a long, rather pointless and somewhat irrational post that in many ways repeats things already stated more than once.
I also agree with
Legate that
Nogrod's reasoning seems a bit dull toDay. Is the old master-hunter losing his touch, or is he no longer himself. Hard to say...
As it stands I might vote
Shasta toDay for reasons I'd rather not disclose at this point... But I'll vote closer to the DL...
A question to
Legate. What makes you single out
Wilwa as especially reasonable?