Quote:
Originally Posted by Formendacil
Basically, I agree that behaviour can be analyzed, but I disagree that it can be done scientifically in the absence of any context. Day 1 will provide context for Day 2's behaviour. Day 1's votes--and the role reveal and the Night kill--will all provide context to analyse Day 1's behaviour.
But during Day 1? It's darts on a dartboard for all a villager could see. You can't see any pattern during its first step.
|
As a scientist, I would love to be scientific, but... it's Tol-in-Gaurhoth. It's
never going to be scientific, and we're fooling ourselves if we think it will.
So yes, I still think it's possible to catch a wolf by their behaviour even on Day One. Forget baselines, and look at
what people are doing. If someone is (say) trying to claim that we can't do anything useful today, whose ends does that serve?
My question to
Legate, for instance, was a test to see if his 'carefree' remark could be a lead-in to arguing that 'X player seems to be carefree, they must be a wolf!'. I wasn't looking for a specific response to indicate This Is A Wolf (/Innocent), obviously - I was just seeing if something popped. My feeling is that his answer didn't lean either way - but it could have.
If we don't push the wolves, they won't slip up. And without knowing who the wolves are, I say that means we push generally and see what moves.
hS
Edit: Crossed since
Formendacil #36.