Since I posted some of my nitpicking on the "Possible Perils" thread, I thought I should come in here and give the other side of the story.
I have to say, that I found Shelob truly frightening, and somehow intelligent and cold-hearted. Her movements were completely believably "spider" and yet calculated. A really masterful combination of some very high-tech effects and thoughtful direction.
Also, I thought the gentleness of the eagles as they carefully plucked Sam and Frodo off the slope of the exploding Mount Doom and flew them to safety was just amazing. I think they would have made Tolkien cry.
__________________
But all the while I sit and think of times there were before,
I listen for returning feet and voices at the door.
|