Quote:
Originally Posted by Inziladun
That said, I don't yet see any reason that I should watch it (which was precisely my view on the PJ film treatments).
|
So as someone who plans to watch the show, my answer is that the reason for the decision has nothing to do with Tolkien. For all intents and purposes, I am pretending this is just another run of the mill unrelated fantasy show, and if they get something right - it's a bonus. And I'll watch for the same reasons that I'd give other shows a shot. I suppose it's a similar attitude I've had to the show Sherlock. It was a pretty good show in early seasons, though the only thing it had in common with Sir Arthur Conan Doyle were a few names. You don't watch it for Doyle, you watch it for the show itself, and enjoy the oblique references to Doyle's stories when they appear.
Now, if they actually make it Tolkien enough that it's recognizably written-ish material, and butcher
that, I might just stop watching, because that
is something that will ruin my appetite.