Quote:
Originally Posted by Michael Murry
Now, does anyone who has read The Silmarillion and seen Game of Thrones have any idea if the richest man on earth will get what he wants out of this television series and whether the "discriminating" television audience will swallow it as J. R. R. Tolkien's work without gagging?
|
Unknown on both, but what the richest man on earth wants is the series to make him lots of money and that may well happen. Fundamentally, this is just an attempt to make a quick buck off the name and work of a better creator.
Whether the discriminating audience will swallow it depends on how the source material is treated, but the philosophical perspectives of Tolkien's work and
Game of Thrones (even as a separate thing from
A Song of Ice and Fire) are miles and miles apart. I have a hard time imagining that they will mesh well.
Quote:
Originally Posted by mhagain
The old complaint that the Amazon series was going to go down the route of GoT style gratuitous titillation seems largely founded on the hiring (or at least advertising for) some kind of "nudity consultant" over a year ago. That's old news and seems disproven by the nudity actually being captured and tortured elves in a concentration camp type scene, possibly in the process of being twisted into orcs. There's seriously no other reason for it, other than unfounded Internet worries.
|
This is not true, at least in my case. I had a bad reaction to the idea the moment I learned of the project and who was behind it. My concerns were increased tenfold when I saw in the statements from Amazon itself that they wanted to mimic the success of
Game of Thrones. Per the links provided by
Michael Murry provide ample evidence that everyone knows why
GoT was so successful. Even the current overall cultural milieu is cause for concern that Tolkien's work will not be treated respectfully.
To the point I made above, based on their own words I think the Amazon production is more sympathetic to the philosophical point of view of
GoT and will have every motivation to titillate the audience because that was the secret to success of
GoT; and that is just one problem (although admittedly a major one) I have with this production.