Quote:
Originally Posted by Lalaith
I was using the Night break to read back over the posts of Day One and I was thinking Morsul's contributions were helpful and sensible, and thus he was probably innocent.
Perhaps the baddies thought this too - in that lots of us might decide to trust him toDay.
|
That would be quite a likely one, too. Or just one of the reasons.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lalaith
So we can assume probably two baddies yesterday and perhaps up to three baddies amongst us today?
|
Which we should pay attention to, btw - because while yesterDay it was either one or two baddies (presumably two), which gets easily lost in a village like this, if it's three now and four (!) toMorrow (or potentially, at least), this can get off the rails very fast.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Eomer of the Rohirrim
But it's the EW who decides the kill, right? So maybe Morsul was a wolf, got sacrificed, and now will be running the Dead Thread because everyone thinks he's innocent? How devious.
I really need to spend a few minutes thinking about the Dead Thread because I'm unsure how much impact it will actually have - maybe I've been overthinking its importance.
|
I think intentionally sacrificing a Wolf to populate the Dead Thread sounds like a scheme
the phantom could come up with, but objectively, it does not make much sense.
Okay, now that I started thinking about it, I *could* imagine a scheme where the EW would just intentionally sacrifice all Wolves and try to completely misinform the village by making them think there are Wolves among them so they would just lynch each other, but really, it does not sound like a very logical strategy.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nerwen
Obviously if his death points to anyone at all, it points to Lottie, but I can't imagine he was killed just for voting her, unless the evil side thought he had dreamed her- i.e. was the GW using his "Seer" ability.
|
Yes, I find it somehow difficult to believe that the Wolves would go for such a straightforward connetion. Even though if
Lottie is evil, maybe the fact that
Morsul was insistent on lynching even though many people were against it might have made the WWs think he knew something? But personally, I think that if you put it that way, it would make more sense if it was an attempt to frame an innocent
Lottie.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mithalwen
Depends on perhaps how significant the vote empowerment thing is? Which will be on a case by case basis as far as I can see. And voting is not always easy to predict and can suprise... so quite a big gamble, to sacrifice a wolf though it seems not theoretically impossible.
|
At least based on experience from previous game, there would need to be significantly large presence of the Wolves on the Dead thread to accomplish anything.
EDIT: ah,
Nogrod is back. Great! Let's have something to read...