Quote:
Originally Posted by Nerwen
...snip-->Tolkien does of course famously play with the "translator conceit", implying that there *is* a "real" version out there- but, again, a conceit is all it is. Now, if your theory is that Frodo falsified the account of what happened at the Council in the Red Book in order to make himself look better, then you need to show some reason why you think we're meant to infer this.
And if neither of those is what you were getting at, I apologise for wasting your time- but I do also think you could be a bit clearer. 
Edit: x'd with Andsigil and Ivriniel. |
That's really interesting materials........I really love the context- or narrative- or positioning of where you're going. I'm going to ponder this one...