So I got caught up with things and haven't had time to do the more detailed analysis of yesterDay I'd planned. So just a few comments.
The
Agan-Lommy spat. Why did so *many* people claim it "looked like wolf-on-wolf", "one of them must be a wolf", etc. I mean, yeah, it's possible, but reading it toDay it looks like just, well, a spat. And I've too often seen wolves circling a brawl between innocents...
Then we have the
Nog-voters. Did
Boro or
Sally ever give reasons for their votes at all? If they did I missed it.
Then we have
Form Nilping himself- some seem to think this looks innocent, but really I cannot imagine why anyone, good or evil, would give himself the third vote at that point.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Firefoot
Anyone else think Mac responded really defensively to what I thought was at best a rather half-hearted accusation? (referencing posts 252 and 281)?
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by mormegil
Yes, and I've felt odd about Mac since early yesterday, hence my vote. Something feels very off. It seems a very forced attempt at being normal. Too much effort into it if that makes sense. To quote Frodo:
"Well, if he was one of the enemy, he would look fairer and...well, feel fouler, if you see what I mean."
He seems opposite to me, he's attempting to look fair but feels foul.
|
I'll third this. There's something wrong about him. Maybe I'm biased by the fact that the last time I was in a game with someone who prattled "helpfully" on and on and on about statistical probabilities, that person turned out to have fur and fangs. (
Mac himself must have known that what he was doing was an academic excercise with no real practical value.) And then there's the thing I noticed toDay (#242)- it does seems to me to have that glimpse-of-the-Nightly-discussion vibe.
Edit:x'd since morm at #285; clarification;word left out.