Mac and
Lommy
Day1: ic banter.
Lommy suspects Nerwen for piggybacking on
Mac's point and throwing suspicion around.
Mac thinks
Lommy is a bit overeager to jump on
Nerwen.
Mac finds
Lommy's ominous maths suspicious but think it would be bold for a wolf.
Mac puts
Lommy in the "no clue" category.
Lommy is baffled by
Mac being more chaotic than in previous games. When discussing potential vote candidates,
Lommy doesn't find
Mac particularly suspicious.
Day2:
Mac considers
Lommy's Day1 vote fishy.
Lommy flip-flops on whether
G55 was killed for looking like a seer, concludes that if yes,
Mac and/or
Volo are most likely behind it.
Lommy files
Mac under "no idea", think he's most likely an ordo or a lover.
Lommy points out
Mac omitted her from his suspicion list, he puts her in his unsure category.
Lommy would prefer
Inzil's lynch over
Mac's, but has the feeling the
Inzil-
Mac war is not leading anywhere.
Conclusions: I have the feeling I might not be qualified to judge.
Mac and
Boro
Day1: ic banter.
Mac files
Boro as "somewhat fishy".
Day2:
Mac mentions the possibility of
Boro being a seer-dreamed innocent.
Mac considers
Boro's Day1 vote fishy.
Mac classifies
Boro as fairly neutral.
Conclusions: Could be anything.
Mac and
Inzil
Day1: mild suspicion against each other.
Mac files
Inzil as "somewhat fishy" and votes him (2nd vote).
Day2:
Inzil says he would've voted
Mac on Day1, had he seen his slip. Still he agrees with
Rikae that killing
Gal would've been risky for wolf-
Mac.
Mac considers
Zil's Day1 vote fishy.
Mac clarifes for
Kit that he suspected
Zil on Day1 because
Zil was so quick to suspect him over something very minor.
Zil understand
Mac's vote on him better than
Boro's.
Mac keeps suspecting
Inzil.
Mac makes a case against
Inzil. Mac lists
Inzil as suspicious.
Inzil refuses to make a case for his defense, saying he's justified his actions already.
Inzil votes
Mac, saying his role would shed light on others'.
Conclusions:
Mac voted
Inzil on both days.
Inzil suspcted
Mac on both days but only voted him on Day2. Some of the suspicion between them was bantery and wishy-washy ("we always suspect each other"), sometimes they brought up actual points against each other and were quite vehemently at each others' throats, which would be rather risky especially in a village with a bear. I think
Inzil looks fairly good but we can't definitely exonerate him yet.
Mac and
Encai
Day1:
Mac discusses
Encai's words on
Inzil. He also considers her innocent.
Day2:
Encai agrees with
Mac about
Wilwa's possible dreams.
Mac considers
Encai's Day1 vote neutral.
Mac lists
Encai as fairly neutral.
Conclusions: could be anything.
Mac and
Eomer
Day1: Discuss the hunter together.
Mac puts
Eomer in the "no clue" category. Banter about the bear.
Mac finishes the Day with feeling better about
Eomer.
Eomer points out that the "
Mac-voters,
G55 and
Wyth, are also very curious..."
Day2:
Mac considers
Eomer's Day1 vote fishy.
Eomer thinks
Mac looks fairly innocent but says he's fine if the rest of the village wants to lynch him.
Mac lists
Eomer as suspicious.
Conclusions: A little fishy.
Mac suddenly starting to suspect
Eomer on Day2 after clearing him in the end of Day1 could either be a wolf in search of people to call guilty, or it could be a wolf seeing the possibility of getting lynched and trying to make a fellow look better by throwing suspicion at them. Also if
Eomer and
Mac were wolves together and
Mac was in danger of lynching I could see
Eomerwolf trying to get someone else lynched but underlining that he's ok with
Mac getting lynched too. Then again he does it in such an in-your-face manner that he would be quite bold.
Mac and
Kitanna
Day1:
Mac mildly suspects
Kit and files her as "somewhat fishy".
Day2:
Mac mentions the possibility of
Kit being a seer-dreamed innocent.
Kitanna discusses the hunter discussion
Mac took part in on Day1 but doesn't conclude whether he looks more guilty or not.
Kitanna questions
Mac's Day1 suspicions.
Mac considers
Kitanna's Day1 vote innocentish.
Kitanna thinks
Mac looks fairly innocent except for his relation to
Wilwa.
Kitanna thinks that the
Mac-voters from Day1 bear having a look at, and considers
Mac himself fairly innocent unless he's the bear.
Mac lists
Kitanna as fairly innocent.
Conclusions: this doesn't really make me any less suspicious of
Kitanna. There's a lot of flip-flopping back and forth and casual suspicion that wouldn't materialize into votes on both sides.
Mac and
Rikae
Day1: lots of bear discussion and banter.
Mac considers Rikae innocent.
Day2:
Rikae discusses
Mac and
Wilwa's interactions in the light of
Wilwa getting bear-killed. Doesn't really reach a conclusion.
Mac mentions the possibility of
Rikae being a seer-dreamed innocent.
Rikae talks with
Inzil about killing
Galadriel being risky for wolf-
Mac. She's wary of
Mac, but mostly because he looks like a potential lover.
Mac considers
Rikae's Day1 vote innocentish.
Rikae maintains that
Mac probably isn't a wolf who thought
G55 the seer.
Rikae and
Mac keep talking about the Day1 role discussion.
Rikae summarizes that she's unsure about
Mac, options seem to be innocent and bear.
Mac lists
Rikae as fairly innocent.
Conclusions: Nothing too incriminating, except from past experience I'm a little baffled why isn't
Rikae toDay all "you wretched
Mac fooled me and were a wolf all along" but rather just amused that he turned out to be a wolf. It's almost like she's not very surprised, which she ought to be if she thought he's an ordo or a lover. As for
Mac's behavior towards her, I can see a wolf-
Mac having good reasons to consider both wolf-
Rikae and innocent-
Rikae innocent, so that doesn't give us much.
Mac and
Lottie
Day1:
Lottie considers
Mac fairly innocent.
Mac is not too concerned about her.
Day2:
Mac considers
Lottie's Day1 vote neutral.
Lottie puts
Mac and
Inzil as her top suspects and suggests they're in cahoots.
Mac defends himself to
Lottie.
Lottie decides to vote
Zil instead of
Mac but maintains they're probably wolves together.
Mac lists
Lottie as fairly neutral.
Conclusions: Okay, so
Lottie picking
Zil instead of
Mac when she needs to make a decision is slightly fishy, but I wonder if as a wolf she would decide to commit like 90% of her energy on Day2 to suspecting her fellow and an unknown for being in cahoots. Seems a little unlikely, as I maintain that it's more likely the wolves would not try to cast too much suspicion on each other in a village with a bear.
Mac and
Nog
Day1:
Nog is very confused by
Mac's fake hunter reveal.
Mac puts
Nog in the "no clue" category.
Nog gives
Mac his fourth vote, although he cross posts with
Greenie who gives the third vote.
Day2:
Mac considers
Nog's Day1 vote neutral.
Nog considers it possible that wolf-
Mac wanted to kill seer-looking
G55, but thinks
Volo is more likely the culprit.
Mac lists
Nog as fairly neutral.
Mac argues that
Nog's vote on him doesn't look lion-on-lion.
Nog is not thrilled about the vote options (including
Mac), but ends up giving him his fifth vote, indicating he thinks
Mac is more likely to be the bear than a wolf.
Conclusions: In theory,
Nog looks fairly good for being an active part of a
Macwagon on both Days. Then again, he does possibly try to get someone else than
Mac lynched on Day2 before he gives up, and I honestly have no idea what on earth is
Mac saying when he's stating that
Nog and
Greenie's votes on him don't look wolf-on-wolf. Also saying like 2min before the DL that
Mac is probably the bear would be a nice touch from a fellow wolf. I'm undecided.
Mac and
Eönwe
Day1:
Mac notes
Eönwë's absence.
Eönwë disagrees with
Mac about the hunter, and says that
Mac (along with a bunch of other people) has said stuff he disagrees with so he'll have a look at him the next Day.
Day2:
Mac considers
Eönwë's Day1 vote neutral.
Mac lists
Eönwë as fairly neutral.
Eönwë lists
Mac as "worrying" without clarifying why.
Eönwë gives
Mac his 6th vote, cross-posting with
Nogrod though. Implies he'd be happy to see either of
Zil or
Mac to go.
Conclusion: I think
Eönwë looks fairly good because of his suspicion of
Mac that doesn't look too wolf-on-wolfy, although of course I can't be sure about him either.
Mac and
Greenie
Day1:
Mac notes her absence.
Greenie agrees with me that
Mac is oddly chaotic and points out his famous "on your side" slip. Gives
Mac his third vote.
Day2:
Mac considers
Greenie's Day1 vote innocentish.
Greenie doesn't think
G55's death incriminates
Mac, but finds him suspicious nevertheless.
Mac lists
Greenie as fairly innocent. Mac argues that
Greenie's vote on him doesn't look lion-on-lion.
Greenie finds
Mac the most suspicious in the village and notes him as one of her preferred vote candidates.
Mac tries to explain his slip to
Greenie.
Greenie almost prefers lynching
Kit to lynching
Mac, but decides to vote
Mac after all.
Conclusions:
Greenie looks very good for pointing out
Mac's slip that one else had noticed after hours had passed. If she's a wolf, she's one of the most heartless bussers I've yet seen (which would be possible but I'd wonder why did she deliberately choose the strategy on already Day1).
Mac and
Copper
Day1:
Mac is not too concerned about
Cop
Day2:
Cop discusses
Mac's fake reveal without reaching a conclusion. Says
Mac and
Nerwen are unlikely to be wolves together. Later finds him mildly suspicious and more confusing, files him under "slightly fishy".
Mac lists
Cop as fairly neutral.
Conclusion: Could be anything.
Mac and
Wyth
Day1:
Mac is not too concerned about
Wyth.
Wyth gives
Mac his second vote because he's one of the two that stand out to him the most.
Day2:
Mac considers
Wyth's Day1 vote fishy.
Mac says that it's possible but unlikely that
Wyth-wolf would have considered himself seer-dreamed by
G55.
Mac finds
Wyth suspiciously defensive.
Wyth replies by pointing out it's the first time ever he's been suspected. In his defense to
Lottie,
Mac keeps saying his suspicion of
Wyth was justified.
Mac lists
Wyth as suspicious but won't vote for him yet.
Wyth changes his mind and says
Mac looks fairly good but mentions he could still be the bear.
Conclusions: I could see a wolf-
Mac and a newbie-wolf-
Wyth interacting in this way, especially with
Mac finding Wyth suspicious but not vote-worthy and
Wyth flip-flopping on Mac once it comes to voting. Then again, all this could be the interaction of a wolf and an innocent.
Mac and
Gil
Day1:
Mac considers
Gil innocent.
Day2:
Mac considers
Gil's Day1 vote neutral.
Mac lists
Gil as fairly innocent.
Gil slightly hesitantly gives
Mac his 3rd vote with lack of better options.
Conclusions:
Gil's vote yesterDay makes him look quite innocent to me. Since he didn't have any real suspicions, he could've gone with anyone but he decided to go with
Mac.
Mac and
Sally
Day1:
Mac puts
Sally in the "no clue" category and notes on her silence.
Day2:
Mac considers
Sally's Day1 vote neutral.
Mac lists
Sally as fairly neutral.
Conclusions: Could be anything.
Summa summarum
possible packmates:
Boro,
Encai,
Eomer,
Kitanna,
Rikae,
Nog,
Copper,
Wyth,
Sally
unlikely packmates:
Inzil,
Lottie,
Eönwë,
Greenie,
Gil
edit: xed with everyone, sheesh, this took ages!