Quote:
Originally Posted by jallanite
Inziladun’s solution to simply ignore Christopher Tolkien’s words in those cases is very unsatisfactory.
|
What's the solution, then? Everyone can't be an
HOME scholar, devoting much time to study of earlier drafts and variants, not to mention various noted and letters produced by J.R.R.T. in his later years. There's an endless capacity for debate if one takes your tack, for the fact is, if CT's version is unacceptable to you, there will
never be an edition that satisfies. If that's all right with you, so be it.
For the purpose of discussion such as we have on this forum, there must be a
standard to base opinions on, and
The Silmarillion, for all its faults, fills the bill. I choose to see the published work as canon, because I do not see how it will be bettered.