Quote:
Originally Posted by A Little Green
What? I'm confused about lover rules in general, but I don't get this point. If the lovers are some different people entirely, then surely even if they haven't found each other yet they'll be able to do the math and realize that both McCaber and Legate can't be lovers if they are, too, so they'd know McCaber was lying. Which would make it a pretty risky lie to tell, I think.
|
True, but I doubt the lovers would want to reveal themselves by pointing fingers at
McCaber. But I still agree it's much more likely
McC is telling the truth, also based on meta reasoning.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Greenie
That doesn't really work, because the theory of packmates giving advice to Echo last Night was based on there having been no Night phase in the beginning of the game, and if there was no Night phase, Copper actually couldn't have said anything to packmates before the game began. So that means that this obstacle to your theory actually doesn't exist!  So yes, theoretically Cop and Echo could be packmates. |
What? No!
Cop's point was that
Echo's more "reasoned" behaviour toDay could be because of packmate briefing last Night and that the briefing couldn't have taken place before Day1 because the game started with a Day phase. My point then was that
Cop sounds almost like she's telling what actually happened last Night in the wolf PM discussion ergo she and
Echo are wolves.
edit: xed with Copper