Probably got presents this year
Sally - the little she's posted seems actually pretty good. She's reasonable and thinks independently. I'd still like to see more from here to judge better.
Morsul - a bit fishy, I admit, but my gut-feeling says innocent. Far from being my top concern atm.
Nerwen - mostly gut-feeling again, but I don't find her very suspicious. I'd like to hear more from her, though.
Legate - his
Boro-suspicion seemed like basic misguided ordo-
Legate 
and today he has a train of thought very similar to my own, which makes me feel good about him. Quite alright for the time being.
The blind spot of my elvish intelligence
Shasta - like
Sally, a quiet and independent poster, but he reminds me a little too much of succesful wolf-
Shastas to make me feel easy about him.
Eönwë - I like his uncompromising thinking (and his jokes!) and he seems reasonable. Then again, there's something about him - notably him seeming a likely packmate for several people - that doesn't really sit right with me.
Zil - I don't know. He's actually under my radar right now. He hasn't really imporved much since yesterDay - in comparison with the general level of discussion (and again it seems he has RL reasons) - but there are way more suspicious people around right now. I'm keeping an eye on him, I guess.
McCaber - he's a little contradictory and mysterious, and his part in yesterDay's voting doesn't look too good. Then again, his tone is honest, if I'm any judge. Keeping an eye on him too.
Probably didn't get presents this year
Galadriel - flimsy reasonings and weird phrasings, plus she's way too self-conscious. Definitely makes my alarm bells ring.
Coppermirror - I really didn't like that pre-written post (both as an idea and the content). Otherwise, not
so bad. Just seems to be off a lot, I wonder if it's confusion or wolvishness.
edit: xed with Zil