Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Nerwen
Has anyone doubted Shasta was Amandil?
|
Sally also mentioned a scenario with the possibility of Amandil still being alive in one of her more recent posts. I don't really understand either why that's even being considered. We know
Shasta was gifted. Why would he false claim as Amandil and why would the real Amandil not counter claim?
Okay, if Elendil was assuming that Anarion was
Boro, I can see why he might not pick
phantom or me. But why
Lottie? She did seem on the more innocent side to me, but there's no way to be sure. And really, what is the bigger risk: sending a dream to a known innocent with the possibility they could die and no information is revealed? Or sending the dream to an unknown who could use that information to manipulate the village should they turn out evil?
I have to be at work for most of toDay, but I will be back for the last one to two hours before deadline.