Quote:
Originally Posted by Nogrod
Hey Coppermirror, nice to have your input. I don't think we have played together earlier. Welcome!
|
Thank you! This is only my second game, but I'm sure I've seen your name before.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nogrod
What you said you didn't get is the following.
Let's say you are a wolf X and you need to get someone killed by the rules which say there has to be at least two votes for the kill to take place in the first place. So how do you pick your choices when the kill demands others (you don't know who they are) to think the same way? So all the "high-profile" players are more probable to enter their lists as any wolf would pick them thinking the others would think like the same... So not so much strategical discussion but trying to make the same pick other wolves would do (in your opinion). So the "obvious ones" die first.
|
That makes some sense. What I didn't understand was why the everyone acting wolvish strategy you proposed would make high-profile players more likely to die, but it seems that's not what you were suggesting after all. Unless I'm still missing something. I am a bit tired today.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pomegranate
I personally think that, given how small the amount of villagers there is compared to the amount of wolves, a technique which will keep us from having something to analyse today and tomorrow could prove to be pretty disastrous. The wolves need information, but I think we need information more.
Also, there is a chance some of the wolves already know each other, since they had a dream last night - obviously we cannot know whether they succeeded, but I think it's a point to remember. And a further point, I think, against just trying to seem wolvish.
|
I think that's persuasive. Today's the day with the lowest chance of the wolves already knowing who the others are. If there isn't any real discussion today, there's no behaviour to compare later behaviour against. And behaviour
should change, sooner or later, unless the wolves are very unlucky with their dreams. I hope that makes sense.
It would be great if some more people would post, but the Day's still young. I hope everyone knows the game is running.