This took me forever to write, and I still haven't come to any conclusions yet.
Summary of Inziladun
DAY 1:
1. Asks me if I've given a pre-emptive defence.
2. Says I'm making a point of distancing myself from the wolves, and that the upside of a small village is that suspicious people are more likely to be wolves than Radagast.
3. Says it's harder for submarines to stay low in a small village. Asks for sub-hunter volunteers.
4. A few small things including "Kit strikes me as a bit off, but it's
really a thin thing."
4. Explains more about sub-hunters. Thanks me for clarifying some things about my behaviour.
5. Says I caused an eyebrow raise but he's not going to vote for me on Day 1. Of
Kitanna says she "still gives some ill-defined feeling of unease, but that's all. " Considers voting for
Shasta or
Sally, seemingly joking.
6. Responds to
Kitanna's call for his reasons. "Just the feel of the first couple of posts. Like I said, it's pretty thin."
7. Goes to bed, hopes to be back before deadline to vote.
8. Briefly mentions everyone but
Shasta and
Galadriel. Says he was trying to use me as wolf bait earlier. Wonders who to vote for:
Kitanna,
Sally or
Nessa.
9. Votes
Kitanna. Says "If she turns out evil, Nerwen, and especially Nessa, might be packmates. If innocent, Sally will look pretty bad in my eyes."
Day 2.
1. Sees no reason for
Nerwen to have been killed. Of his vote, says he "decided that it was more unlikely Sally as a wolf would have latched onto Kit the way she did, than it was that Kit herself was evil. I wasn't all that enthused about voting Kit, I just didn't see any better options." Says things would have changed if he'd seen
Nessa's vote.
2. Says "What I said about Coppermirror I saw as both a noteworthy mention, as well as an opportunity to see if anyone else suspiciously latched onto it.
My words about Kit had no such secondary thought behind them." Had thought yesterDay that "it might be that Nerwen, by casting suspicion on Sally for voting Kit, and Nessa for echoing it, might be packmates of Kit".
3. Says "
Nessa's vote looks inexplicable. I suppose it's possible she put in a vote for a packmate-
Pitch".
4. After
Kitanna's post, he claims to be the Seer. Says he voted for
Kitanna on Night 1 and was gunning for her with the "vague suspicion". Claims his dream last night was
Nerwen.
5. Tried to be vague enough that the wolves wouldn't kill him, but to give enough info that villagers could go after her after his death. Thought that "
Nerwen might have been trying to raise
Sally as an alternative lynch to
Kit" and dreamed of her for that reason.
6. Votes for
Kitanna.
7. Says people are free to ask questions.
8. Gives his opinions of guilt/innocence.
Of me: probably innocent.
Of
G55: probably innocent.
Of
Sally: doesn't strike him as a likely wolf.
Of
Shasta: doesn't come to a firm conclusion. Mistrusts him in general. Wonders why he would vote for
Nessawolf if he's also a wolf.
Of
Pitch: finds him enigmatic. Likes his skepticism in sorting between the Seers. Wonders why
Nessa went for him: a throwaway vote, or a wolf wanting to vote for a packmate who was unlikely to be lynched?
Of
Eomer: trips his radar. Thinks
Eomer deliberately misunderstood his intentions with his plan earlier. "his vote for
Sally could be his picking up on what
Nerwen had said, trying to divert things away from
Nessa"
9. Leaves to go to bed. "If possible I'll try to check in before DL, but don't count on it. "
Summary of Kitanna
DAY 1:
1. Two very trivial posts with little content. Understandable given the point in time. Leaves.
2. Comes back, says it seems as if not much has happened and she'll be reading what's happened.
3. Asks for a reason for
Inzil's vague feelings of suspicion. "I'd like a reason. I've said almost nothing."
4. Says there's not much she can say that hasn't been said and resaid.
5. Says
Eomer must know the game has started. (Not suspicious.)
6. "I guess I woke up just in time to see votes garnered against me for being vaguely uncomfortable and creepy." Says will probably vote for
Inzil as doesn't like his vague feeling and doesn't like the way he claimed to have tried baiting people with me and not her.
7. Votes for
Inzil. "I don't trust anything he's said. I'm especially annoyed that he claimed to "bait" Coppermirror, but accused me."
DAY 2:
1. Claims to be the Seer, and claims that she's seen
Inzil is a wolf. Says she assumed she would be lynched yesterDay and almost didn't make it.
2. Claims to have dreamt of an innocent on Night 1, and
Inzil on Night 2. Says she has a terrible record as a Seer and that sacrificing herself now makes sense.
3. Says that there's nothing she can do to convince us of her innocence over
Zil's fake reveal, and that
Zil wants us to waste the day. Says that
Zil's other dream is conveniently dead. Refuses to give the name of a living known innocent to a village which doesn't trust her.
4. Responds to
Pitchwife's concern about why she won't reveal the Innocent: "I've given you a wolf already. And if that still gets me lynched I don't feel inclined to help this village further. I will reveal my dream if this village trusts me enough to lynch Zil." and "You may all waste the day trying to decide who you want to believe. I have nothing left to say on the topic. Once I get back to my house I will concentrate on finding the third wolf."
5. Analyses a number of villagers.
Of me: "That makes me wary, but I'm not sold on her as guilty. I'm not convinced she's innocent either. I'd like to see what else she has to say".
Of
Shasta: Thinks he looks slightly innocent because he gave the first vote for
Nessa. Doesn't like that he didn't give much of a reason for that vote.
Of
Sally: Says she looks like a frustrated innocent crunched for time.
Of
Galadriel55: Doesn't know what to make of her. Agrees with her point that a vote for someone who isn't there is easy to hide behind. Thinks it's interesting so many of her suspects are dead, and though she can see her steering votes to packmates, doesn't know if it would happen on Day 1.
Of
Eomer: Thinks he may well be Wolf#3. Wants a closer watch kept on him regardless of what happens toDay.
Of
Pitch: "Pitch is probably innocent."
She also adds that "I am being quite angry with this village and am going to keep my dream to myself. It's thanks to Zil who refuses to go down, but just wants to confuse things. I'm frustrated and angry. I also have nothing to lose but my own life at this point."
6. Responds to
Sally's vote for her with a mock vote for herself. "Just don't kill Sally. She's my other packmate."
This post is getting long, so I'm going to consider my suspicions in a second one. (I still have to write it! This is taking quite some time.)
Anyway, my initial position was one of suspicion for
Inzil because it seemed as if a wolf-
Kitanna would have little to gain from coming forward. But once
Kitanna started posting more about being the Seer, she started sounding really suspicious for her sudden anger at the village and refusal to name the other known innocent (...but I don't see what a wolf would have to gain from that). I'm not confident enough to come to any conclusions yet. I want to consider everything carefully. I'm going to get back to a proper analysis now.
But for the meantime,
Kitanna, if you're around now and if you're the Seer, why are you angry with the village? Why are you abandoning us? Please come back and give us the name of the known innocent.
Unfortunately I wasn't here early enough to ask
Inzil questions. Although I haven't got any questions in mind yet, I'm sure I will soon.