Quote:
Originally Posted by Mithalwen
And while the sets costumes and props were my favourite aspect, I wish the Hobbit had been treated independently. Jackson's is not the only possible vision, Those of us who knew the books first have our own and that must be "with knobs on" for CRT. He can have absolutely no need of film to make Middle Earth come to life. I don't see an inconsistency with the opinions expressed. He didn't think the book suitable and was not pleasantly surprised.
|
The question of other visions than PJ's moves me to wonder what CT thought of the Rankin-Bass and Bakshi animated movies.
Personally, even though they are hardly high works of art, nor are they slavishly faithful to the books (to say the
least 
), I've got a soft spot in my heart for them, and do not harbor the same dislike I have for the live action treatments. I don't know if it's due to the fact that I saw them as a child and never took them seriously to begin with, or if it's more the lingering frustration that PJ got just enough right that his errors were simply that much more magnified and hard to forgive.
Did CT ever give an opinion of the earlier attempts?