Using
Legate's analysis about
Nogrod's comments about everybody (#
366), and my analyses (#
398, #
437) about others' comments about him (and omitting myself of course):
Unlikely packmates
Pitch - when he criticises the
Bom-lynch, his main target is very clearly
Nogrod, not
Shasta,
Legate,
Eönwë or me. In a few other occassions, he is rather aggressive towards him. I'm not sure of this new, more aggressive style of
Pitch's, but I can't see him coming up with it as a wolf and applying it mostly wolf-on-wolf, it is potentially dangerous to the pack and puts him rather in the spotlight.
Shasta - his rather loud attack on
Nogrod on Day1 doesn't reveal much, neither does the subsequent interaction, but: why the heck would a wolf-
Shasta tainted himself by the association by suggesting lynching
Zil the supposed acolyte instead of
Nog the wolf? Surely that would have been too brazen?
These two are not exonerated by this, but I think it makes them look better enough that we should let them be for toDay which is the critical Day.
Possible packmates
Lottie -
Nog attacked him on Day1, which would make her look more innocent than not. (Would a wolf-
Nog bus fellow
Lottie who is always suspected on Day1? That would be a bit too mean, taking into account that
Lottie is someone who plays "properly" by
Nog's standards.) Otherwise not much to conclude from: slight suspicion/ neutrality towards each other,
Lottie believed
Steve's revelation immediately like most of the people.
Likely packmates
Boro - on Day1, he talks uncharacteristically little about
Nogrod, almost seems to avoid him.
Nog suspects him, but doesn't seem to seriously consider voting him. On Day2 they argue,
Boro defends
Steve for attacking
Nog but is himself very conflicted about
Nog's role until
Steve's reveal, when he turns almost malicious. To me, this seems like the exact way
Borowolf would act with fellow
Nog and wanting to keep all possibilities open about a packmate... Then again,
Nogrod was pretty contradictory on the Day he died.
Pom -
Nogrod is pretty nice to her in a way I can't really make sense of, maybe more like wolf to innocent. Then again, what she says about him is rather fishy: a few times she raises some point point about him, discusses it and concludes nothing. She suspects him but concludes he answered her suspicions pretty well. Makes her a more likely packmate of
Nog's than many others.
Greenie -
Nogrod suspects her a little, she scarcely mentions him, then in a list she says she has mixed feelings about him and votes
Eönwë who attacked him. Hmm... looks almost too obvious wolf-on-wolf.
Sally - they mention each other so little it would be a perfect wolf-on-wolf tactic. Sally's suspicion of him is so "mainstream" we can hardly conclude anything from it.
Hmm... so if I had to bet, I would guess a
Nog-
Boro-
Pom-
Sally pack, but substituting any of them (except for
Nog of course
) with
Greenie or even
Lottie is of course possible. (
Pitch,
Shasta and
Lottie, if you are the remaining wolves, feel free to laugh at me.
)
In any case I will still do a lot of rethinking and rereading toDay, because we cannot make any conclusions too fast toDay (so I reserve the right to change my opinion, thank you!)