Quote:
|
Originally Posted by G55
Quote:
Originally Posted by Greenie
And if she's really the Hunter, there's no way the wolves are going to go after her now - thus narrowing their options for the Seer, and basically making her own gift useless.
|
You're forgetting about the third gifted. The Ranger can do miracles. |
Meaning?
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by G55
Quote:
Originally Posted by Greenie
ideally, we'd spend the Day discussing who she should take with her, and when she dies it all turns out to be for nothing
|
.
No, we won't. She can't choose her pick during the Day. And it's supposed to be a surprise during the Night, a secret weapon, so why would we tell the wolves "sally's hunting X toNight"? |
Um... I think
Greenie's talking about a
Sally–as–Cobbler scenario there,
G55– though she certainly could have been clearer about it.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by G55
@Kit: If you think that sally could be the cobbler, which role do you think Nog has? They can't both be cobblers, and Nog just as good as fake-revealed Seer.
|
Well, what he did yesterDay was darned peculiar, I'll grant you that. Are you sure he
meant it to be taken as a reveal, though? Seers can't usually see the Cobbler, after all. (Don't think that's been clarified for this game.)
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by G55
So far there's me and Bom thinking sally has the village's best intentions at heart, and Greenie and Nerwen thinking that she doesn't, and Kit undecided. Is that right?
|
I'd say I'm more "undecided". I don't think what she's doing is in the village's interests– but I can't yet rule out that she
thinks it is. It's hard to know where you are with
Sally– she likes to pull weird stunts now and then, whatever her role.