[Shastanis Althreduin]

On Aganzir, Day 1

#18 - No real content. Several things in this post could be taken to be hints to people (Bom, G55, me) but I can't say for sure.

#50 - Agrees with Nog that Bom is just adding to the confusion, but she's not willing to vote for him.

This post has the quote that originally drew my attention to Agan. Here it is below -

Originally Posted by Aganzir

Or someone being gifted. I wouldn't say Bom's behaviour has been unusual enough to merit either title, but I do wonder why you didn't think of the other option.

This pounce on Lottie bothers me. For one, why assume Lottie didn't think of the other possibility and choose not to mention it (like an innocent should)? For another, why draw attention to a possible Gifted!Bom yourself in the first place? It doesn't sit right with me.

Mentions Pitch is erroneous in saying "there was a wolf involved in the early talk". I agree here, but not to the extent that it makes Pitch looks suspicious like Agan thinks.

Says she's going to vote for me, Lottie, or Pitch. It's interesting to note that the only thing Agan has said about me thus far is that I "feel sneaky" and she still "feels bad" about me.

#58 - Defends Nog pretty passionately here, against Greenie (and this is in response to Inzil.) Puts more pressure on Pitch (and this looks somewhat like the beginning of a witchhunt.)

#60 - Mentions Greenie and Inzil together again, probably because of their votes for Nog. Mentions Inzil has already been voted for, but that she's "not sure if it was ever going to turn into a bandwagon" which is a comment I don't understand.

#62 - Vote count.

#66 - This is an interesting post. Agan says she's flip-flopping on Lottie, but the content of the post appears to say the opposite - Agan mentions that Greenie singled out one part of a three-part Lottie statement to respond to, which is strange, I'll agree. Lottie's response to that makes sense to me and is normal enough, though. What I find the most interesting is this -

Originally Posted by Aganzir

So how did it become about the cobbler? As I see it, Lottie originally also offered two other options! It looks like they're both reading too much into it: first Greenie grasps at a part of a sentence, then Lottie immediately backs off.
Weirdos.

The way I read into this bit is Agan offering up food for thought to the village in general and stepping back to wait for reactions... which isn't typical of Agan in my experience. Hmm.

#69 - Responds to me about Lottie and Bom. Agan raises a good point here about "unusual" meaning "not ordinary" rather than "wolfish", but I don't think simply pointing out behavior that appears unusual is as big a point against Lottie as Agan is trying to make it out to be.

#70 - Question to Lottie - "And why would a wolf do that?" Unfair question - what a wolf would do depends on any number of factors, like who the wolf is, what the situation is, etc. Again, looks like a prelude to a wolf hunt - Agan looks like she's waiting to pounce on whatever answer Lottie gives, no matter what it is.

#78 - Agan answers what I said with "Yep, I did, so what, oh well." I'm thinking of leaving apple cores in her bed for this.

#79 - Agan dismisses outright Lottie's theory about Bom under her own theory that the risk of being dreamed is too great. Seems a bit silly to me - finding the cobbler is a nice bonus for the Seer, but not the main priority. I think Lottie's theory is valid, personally. And why even bother with that "if I was a Gifted" business?

#88 - Another vote count.

#91 - Another vote count.

#94 - Votes Inzil (a far cry from a) where her suspicions were and b) who she said she'd vote.)

#96 - Tells Nog to go to bed.




Thoughts -

Agan evidences suspicion of me (for being sneaky), but all day her main target was Lottie. The only thing she said about Inzil was in regards to defending Nogrod. Since the only reason I can see Agan voting Inzil is to save Nog, I find it interesting that the very first thing Agan says starting Day 2 is "I am torn about Nog" (which is a far cry from the absolute trust she had in him Day 1) but doesn't go on to explain why, really.