Quote:
Originally Posted by Pitchwife
In terms of lying/not telling the whole truth, we might say Dumbledore is modelled more on Star Wars' Obi-wan Kenobi than on Gandalf - although I'd say Obi-wan himself (at least in the first trilogy, disregarding the prequels) was modelled on Gandalf to some degree.
|
Well, you know, in all this talk of
Harry Potter being "stolen" from
Tolkien, I don't think anyone's mentioned that the phrase "join the Dark Side" occurs in the very first book. Now
there's stealing for you!
Seriously– my own reservations about the HP series have nothing to do with (supposed) theft. It's more that I think Rowling's pretty limited as a writer, and that the ambitiousness of the later books only serves to highlight this. Obviously the real fans aren't going to agree with me here, but I just feel she ends up biting off more than she can chew.