Quote:
Originally Posted by elbenprincess
In the appendix of LOTR he said she was "the greatest of even women". What do you think? Is that time - related and excludes Luthien because she no longer lives on Arda or does that include Luthien?
|
Well, firstly, "greatest" is not necessarily "most beautiful". And I guess that Luthien doesn't count as she isn't alive anymore.
Quote:
|
Interesting quote it is! So is she even more beautiful than Arwen? How can this be, if Arwen is the likeness of Luthien? Or is Arwen excluded because she, until he end of the third age, didnīt decided to what race she wants to belong?
|
Arwen's beauty was like an echo of Luthien's. That's how I see it. And they are both beautiful. Beauty is a thing of opinion, and there were some disputes *coughGimliandEomercough*
.